In a recent testimony before the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Natural Resources, Jim Donofrio, Executive Director of the Recreational Fishing Alliance (RFA), emphasized the need for more flexibility in the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act (MSA) to effectively rebuild fisheries.

Testimony Overview

On December 5, 2007, in Washington, D.C., the RFA shared its perspective on the challenges faced under the current provisions of the MSA. Highlighting the case of the summer flounder—a key recreational species along the East Coast—Donofrio illustrated how the existing legislation restricts fishery managers despite significant improvements in the species’ population.

Significant Progress in Summer Flounder Recovery

Donofrio reported notable advancements in the summer flounder fishery, with the stock reaching its largest size in 25 years. He noted a dramatic reduction in fishing mortality by over 80% and a total harvest decrease of over 96%. Furthermore, total stock biomass and spawning stock biomass have surged by 251% and 280%, respectively.

Calls for Legislative Flexibility

During the hearing, Congressman Frank Pallone (D-NJ) acknowledged the need for more legislative flexibility in the MSA, a move welcomed by Donofrio. The RFA leader stressed that without adjustments to the law, fishery managers are bound by “unrealistic and unachievable expectations.”

Controversy Over Fishing Moratoriums

The RFA also responded to proposals from environmental groups like the Pew Environmental Group, which advocated for a 10-year moratorium on summer flounder fishing. Donofrio criticized these groups for their transparent motives, likening the situation to the previously successful rebuilding of the striped bass fishery, yet facing unprecedented restrictive quotas.

Conclusion and Forward Look

Reflecting on the hearing, Donofrio expressed gratitude for the opportunity to represent recreational fishermen and praised the bipartisan interest in revising the MSA. He emphasized the necessity for common-sense revisions that acknowledge the limits of fisheries science and the inherent uncertainties of marine environments.

Closing Remarks

Jim Donofrio concluded his testimony by thanking Congressman Pallone for initiating the hearing and other committee members for their engagement in this critical issue, signaling a hopeful path toward more adaptable and effective fisheries management.